Sun 21 Sep 2008
SPECIAL SUNDAY EDITION: NY Times Puts LIRR’s Balls in a Vise, Tightens
Posted by TJ under Edward Koerber, LIRR, Martin Dickman, Railroad Retirement Board
If you ride the Long Island Railroad or Metro-North, or in any way pay taxes in America, spend the next 20 minutes reading this because some fat Long Island golf guys are stealing your money.
The NY Times has flat-out blasted the L.I.R.R. in a front-cover, 5,000-word story on the scam railroad workers are pulling to command massive paychecks after they’ve retired.
In short, just about every career LIRR worker claims medical disability when he or she retires, and unless they completely botch the paperwork, they get it. Last year, 94% of career LIRR employees who retired after age 50 got disability benefits; fully 97% qualified in 2004. That’s on top of a retirement package that would be the envy of just about anyone I know.
The Times sicced a crew of eight reporters on this one, and they delivered the goods. It appears arthritis and rheumatism is the malady of choice for retiring LIRR guys. From 2001 to 2007, LIRR had 753 claims for both. By comparison, Metro-North–a railroad of a similar size, with similar staff duties–had 32. 32!
If you don’t ride one of those two railroads, you’re probably wondering what all this has to do with you. Well, those claims are paid out in part by Social Security. In fact, Social Security–your retirement home in Boca, your Schlitz money for the final decade of your life–coughed up $3.6 billion on the railroad’s disability claims that were signed off on by the Railroad Retirement Board.
The Times bloodhounds trace the Railroad Retirement Board, a federal organization created in the ’30s, to a crummy insurance office in Chicago. It’s manned by three presidentially appointed employees.
Aptly named Retirement Board inspector general Martin Dickman offered a classic case of passing the buck in his defense of the Board’s nearly 100% approval rate of disability claims (they are only turned down when an applicant fails to complete the paperwork.)
Dickman…acknowledged in an interview that the retirement board’s rejection rate was “almost nonexistent,” but he added: “If Congress wants to change the statute and raise the threshold, that’s up to Congress. That’s not up to us to do.”
The story also unearths some extremely dubious overtime loopholes that are built into the LIRR contracts. It sets the microscope on one Edward J. Koerber, an engineer who routinely got paid for four days while working one–all legal, thanks to arcane LIRR contracts.
Koerber worked his scam–actually, not even a scam, all legal–to boost his annual nut to $276,456–mighty close to LIRR president Helena Williams’ salary of $287,658. Koerber, a heavy-set fellow with a walrus moustache, would quadruple his pay by operating a train with an electric engine (not part of his job duty, extra day’s pay), moving said train to the service yard (not part of his job duty, another extra day’s pay), and accumulating “penalty payments” for things like skipping lunch. (Judging by the Times photo of Koerber, I don’t think he actually skipped too many lunches.)
Edward Koerber, Quarter-Million Dollar Man
Insiders commenting on behalf of LIRR say the railroad is essentially powerless to fight this costly waste, due to the threat of a strike. If the fat-ass engineers and conductors choose to strike, the Metro area is crippled, and the public doesn’t care who’s right or wrong–they just want their 7:07 from Huntington back.
And what do all those able-bodied-yet-disabled retirees do with all their free time? They play golf…for free, no less, thanks to an “Access Pass” for all disabled persons that allows them free activities at state parks.
Scuzzbags.
Metro-North actually comes across as a band of gentlemen, compared to those Long Island scalawags.
“We don’t have full-day penalty payments here,” says Jane Murawski, assistant director of labor relations at Metro-North. “It would never be that the person works their eight-hour shift and then they get another eight hours and another eight hours for other things. That doesn’t happen here.”
Metro-North, formed in 1983 from the old Conrail commuter lines, largely inherited the work rules of its parent, which was mostly a freight railroad. But because the L.I.R.R. has always been primarily a commuter railroad, many existing labor agreements remained after the authority took it over in 1966.
The disparity in pay between the two railroads is considerable. At the L.I.R.R, 107 nonmanagement workers earned more than $150,000 in 2006, compared with only a handful at Metro-North.
“We have the best work rules in the industry nationwide — I would say worldwide,” said Mr. Quinn, the official with the Long Island chapter of the engineers union. “They’ve never been able to negotiate them away from us.”
It is features such as this that make me uneasy to think about the massive layoffs hitting the newspaper industry. Who besides the NY Times has the resources to put into such a story, and who’s even going to think about doing such enterprise reporting five or ten years down the road?
[top image: NY Times. Disabled LIRR guy Joseph Rutigliano playing golf on your dime.]
8 Responses to “ SPECIAL SUNDAY EDITION: NY Times Puts LIRR’s Balls in a Vise, Tightens ”
Comments:
Leave a Reply
Trackbacks & Pingbacks:
-
Pingback from LIRR-DISABILITY SCANDAL: FBI Raids Retirement Board’s L.I. Office » trainjotting.com
September 24th, 2008 at 8:30 am[…] Day Three of the Long Island Railroad/Employee Disability Scam Scandal (LIRREDSS), federal agents raided the Westbury offices of the Railroad Retirement Board, the shady […]
-
Pingback from Bobby the Conductor: When Riders Attack » trainjotting.com
September 25th, 2008 at 8:44 am[…] A savvy Long Island Railroad conductor might’ve parlayed that into full disability! « Google Can Help You With Your Train Commute | […]
September 21st, 2008 at 11:50 pm
TJ, the New York Times has a whole video on it.
http://video.on.nytimes.com/?fr_story=9b6b3c42e570cc254ece57e2938ad36b812ca368
September 22nd, 2008 at 3:36 pm
LIRR employees pay huge amnts of cash into RR RETIREMENT SYSTEM. yOUR PRESIDENT IS BAILING OUT EVERY BROKE COUNTRY AND BUISNESS THAT IS IN TROUBLE IN THE WORLD. hE IS WRITING CHECKS FOR BILLIONS TO AFRICA FOR AIDS RESEARCH. ( DID YOU EVER GETTO VOTE ON THAT?) tAXPAYERS ARE PAYING IT. AT LEAST THE MONEY THE lirr GUYS ARE GETTING IS SPENT IN THE usa AND BY THE WAY IT IS FEDERALLY TAXED. LIKE ANY ONE OF YOU WOULDNT TAKE AN EXTRA DAYS PAY FOR A CONTRACT NEGOTIATION VIOLATION. oH NO THANKS BOSS i’LL JUST TAKE THE 1 DAYS PAY SO i CAN BE A NICE GUY. SOUNDS LIKE SOUR GRAPES TO ME. JEALOUSY IS A STRONG EMOTION.
September 22nd, 2008 at 6:34 pm
I guess you make less than Mr. Koerber did. Instead of knocking his work rules, why not get a better job, or put in a resume?
Most LIRR employees make in the six figures just as do most cops and garbage men here on Long Island.
Why not start your own railroad and pay people $10/hour? Then see who runs the trains on Christmas Eve.
Sour grapes.
September 23rd, 2008 at 11:59 am
Sour grapes as paid by the tax payers and train riders, most of whom can’t retire at 50 at $250K per with free golf. It’s fraud, plain and simple.
September 27th, 2008 at 9:41 pm
Like it or not, as the RRB IG said, “It’s the law.” Applying for what is yours is not fraud, plain and simple.
Maybe you should try to get job there.
October 3rd, 2008 at 11:32 pm
All who are complaining are just jealous that THEY don’t have those work rules, or the pay the LIRR workers do.
What pisses me off is that these people that wear the suits and push papers and pencils all day long are making the most money and doing the least work. They aren’t out in the elements, making sure your precious son or daughter, husband or wife gets home safely and on time. It’s the WORKERS that do. And if they’re willing to work 7 days a week, holidays and whenever they’re needed, then they should get paid extra for it.
Does Helena Williams’ position require her to go out and be on the tracks in 100+ degree days in the summer, or shovel 6+ inches of snow in the winter at 10 different stations, or hear a horn blare from right underneath you 21 times within an hour, or have to deal with the spoiled, nasty commuters that her company carts around 7 days a week? Does she leave her husband and kids on Thanksgiving or Christmas because she has to work? No to all of it. Management gets to leave early on Christmas eve and has off the day after Thanksgiving, along with all major holidays-all paid as full 8 hour days. (Most managers don’t even deal with the public).
Some of those workers that make “all that money” are working those holidays. So why shouldn’t they get more?
The “fat-ass” conductors and engineers are trained for an extensive period of time to earn they pay that they get. Not everyone can hold those positions. If they could, wouldn’t you be here?